The great debate: Should you use bit.ly/yourlink or create links.yourbrand.com?

Everyone has opinions. "Branded links build trust!" versus "Free tools work fine!" But nobody talks about what actually matters: governance, tracking accuracy, and scale.

Let's settle this with data, not feelings.

What Matters (tracking, trust)

Before choosing tools, know what you're optimizing for.

Tracking Accuracy: Can you see exactly who clicked what, when, from where? If your data is muddy, nothing else matters.

Brand Trust: Do people trust your links enough to click? A sketchy-looking URL kills conversions before they start.

Governance: Can you update, redirect, or fix broken links after posting? One wrong link in a viral post can waste thousands of clicks.

Scale: Works for 10 links? Great. How about 1,000? Tool choice changes with volume.

Cost: Free is nice until limitations kill growth. Paid is fine if ROI justifies it.

Most creators optimize for the wrong thing (cost) instead of the right thing (control).

Shorteners Pros/Cons

Link shorteners are the fast food of URL management. Quick, cheap, gets the job done.

Pros of Shorteners:

  • Free to start (bit.ly, rebrand.ly, tinyurl)

  • Instant setup (no technical knowledge)

  • Built-in analytics dashboard

  • Works immediately

  • Automatic QR codes

  • Bulk creation tools

Cons of Shorteners:

  • You don't own the domain

  • Service could die (RIP goo.gl)

  • Free tier limitations (100 links, basic analytics)

  • Generic looking (bit.ly screams "marketing")

  • Shared reputation (if others spam, you suffer)

  • Platform blocks (some sites ban shortened URLs)

Best For: Testing ideas, side projects, quick campaigns, creators under 10K followers.

Branded Domain Setup

Your own domain shortener is like owning vs renting. More work upfront, total control forever.

Setting Up links.yourbrand.com:

Option 1: Simple Redirects (5 minutes)

Option 2: WordPress Plugin (20 minutes)

  • Install Pretty Links or ThirstyAffiliates

  • Create short links in dashboard

  • Track clicks internally

Option 3: Dedicated Service (Best)

  • Use Short.io or Rebrandly paid

  • Connect your domain

  • Full analytics + governance

  • Scale to thousands

Real Example Setup:

  1. Buy domain: $12/year

  2. Create subdomain: free

  3. Connect to Short.io: $29/month

  4. Total: $41/month for unlimited branded links with analytics

Governance Rules

Governance is what separates professionals from amateurs. It's link management at scale.

Essential Governance Rules:

Naming Convention:

Redirect Maps:

  • Document every link created

  • Include original URL

  • Note publish date

  • Track performance

Update Protocol:

  • Old campaigns redirect to /start

  • Broken links fixed within 24 hours

  • Seasonal updates planned ahead

Access Control:

  • Who can create links?

  • Who can see analytics?

  • Who can modify redirects?

  • Document everything

Testing Frequency:

  • Weekly: Top 10 links

  • Monthly: All active links

  • Quarterly: Full audit

Without governance, you're one broken link away from losing thousands of potential customers.

Decision Tree

Stop overthinking. Follow this decision tree:

Start with shorteners if:

  • Under 10K followers

  • Testing content strategy

  • Budget under $50/month

  • Need solution today

  • Simple tracking enough

Move to branded domain when:

  • Over 10K followers

  • Running paid ads

  • Building email list seriously

  • Need advanced analytics

  • Want total control

Hybrid Approach (What Pros Do):

  • Branded domain for permanent links (bio, email signature)

  • Shorteners for testing (new campaigns, A/B tests)

  • Platform-specific for platform features (YouTube, LinkedIn)

  • Direct links for trusted audiences (email list)

Example Split:

Cover all bases, maximize control.

Your links are too important for random decisions. Choose tools that match your growth stage and governance needs.

Start with our Automation Starter Checklist using any link tool. Ready to scale? Join the Smart Link Builder waitlistfor our upcoming automated solution.

Educational content only. No business, financial, or results guarantees. Implement at your own discretion.

Keep Reading

No posts found